Optimism in the Face of Defeat in the Bayview

Pub date June 3, 2008
SectionPolitics Blog

Text and Photos by Umayyah Cable

Having just left the HQ of the F is for Fairness campaign in the Bayview, I must report that the vibe was generally optimistic despite the fact that Prop F was decidedly dragging it’s feet through the election mud. Members of the campaign were staying positive as they gathered in a rented space on 3rd street, eagerly refreshing the SF Departments of Elections results page. Here’s a glimpse of the evening:

bayviewelection02.gif

bayviewelection01.gif

bayviewelection05.gif

bayviewelection04.gif

bayviewelection03.gif

As I was uploading these images I now find that Prop F has officially failed. Which makes the above pictures out dated and bittersweet.

While talking with members of the campaign, many of whom happen to also be members of the Grace Tabernacle Church in the Bayview, I was struck by a specific emotional aspect of Prop F that I hadn’t previously considered. In speaking with Jesse, a congregation member who wore a “YES on F” T shirt in Spanish, and a windbreaker jacket proudly emblazoned with an “I voted!’ sticker, I really got a sense of what this decision could actually mean for this community. Jesse spoke of raising his 9 children in the neighborhood (who are now raising his 27 grandchildren), coaching baseball, and looked on with pride and affection at the group of teenagers sitting across the hall from us.

If Lennar has its way with the Bayview and Hunter’s point neighborhoods of San Francisco, all those things which Jesse and many others hold dearest to them: children, family, and fostering a tight knit community, will be replaced by an overpriced playground for yuppies. Lennar will take its mountain of paper money and replace children and community with materialism and greed. And what’s a city without children? Futureless, directionless and growthless.

I must say, the results are somewhat disheartening. But given the optimism I witnessed this evening, I have some renewed faith that this community wont give up without a fight.